ALL >> Legal >> View Article
Second District Court Of Appeal Overturns Lower Court's Ruling Based On Illegal Search
In the case of Forman v. State, the Court of Appeal reversed defendant's conviction & sentence for possessing cocaine in an occurrence stemming from an automobile accident. The defendant was traveling as a passenger in a vehicle that was involved in a car accident where the driver of that car was not at fault. After arriving as backup at the scene of the accident, a police officer saw defendant sitting in the front passenger seat of the car. The police officer testified in court that defendant was rocking back & forth in the seat and that he ordered defendant to exit the vehicle for officer safety. In his testimony, the officer was not to give any particular facts to justify his concern for officer safety. Defendant initially refused, but the officer ordered the defendant to get out of the vehicle. When the defendant was out of the car, the police officer noticed a bulge in defendant's waistband, searched him, & located cocaine. The defendant filed a motion to suppress at trial, but it was denied.
On appeal, the circuit court noted that, if defendant had been traveling as a passenger in a vehicle ...
... that had been legally stopped, the trial court would have been correct in denying defendant's motion to suppress. However, in this case the vehicle had been involved in a automobile accident and was not lawfully stopped. The District Court of Appeal based their ruling on the holding in Miranda v State. Miranda held that an officer cannot order a party to exit a vehicle without having reasonable suspicion that a crime has occurred. Therefore, the court overturned the denial of the defendant's motion and ordered the trial court to vacate his judgment and sentence.
For more information on DUI Attorney Fort Lauderdale FL , Criminal Attorney Fort Lauderdale FL and DUI Attorney Fort Lauderdale FL you can contact us at: The Law Offices of Michael A. Dye, PA 1 E Broward Blvd # 700, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
(954) 990-0525
Add Comment
Legal Articles
1. Best Cyber Crime Lawyer In Ghaziabad – Advocate DeepakAuthor: Advocate Deepak
2. Revealed: Secret Strategies To Dominate Government Sales On Gem!
Author: Bidz Professional
3. What To Look For In An Experienced Ri Divorce Lawyer
Author: John Grasso
4. Everything You Need To Know Before Investing In Saudi Arabia
Author: jodonjo
5. Spousal Alimony In California: What It Is And How It's Decided
Author: Thomas D. Nares
6. Balancing Investor Protection And Industry Growth: Sebi Lawyers' Take On Investment Advisers’ Reforms
Author: Dev kumar
7. "transparent Processes: Building Public Trust Through Stringent Pcc Attestation Measures"
Author: shareeba
8. How To Open An Llc As A Saudi
Author: jodonjo
9. Navigating The Road To Recovery After A Minneapolis Truck Accident: Why A Local Attorney Is Key
Author: sussmanlaw
10. Uk Spouse Visa Explained: How To Join Your Partner In The Uk
Author: The SmartMove2UK
11. How A Drug Lawyer Can Challenge Unlawful Searches And Seizures
Author: glennrroderman
12. The Role Of Gmp And Haccp Certifications In The Global Food Industry
Author: URS Certification
13. Public Procurement Rules Revised To Push Make In India Initiative
Author: Dev kumar
14. Lawyer In Jaipur | Best Lawyer In Jaipur
Author: RN Mittal & Associates
15. Uk Visa Refusal: Key Reasons And What To Do Next
Author: The SmartMove2UK