Minidiscs - An Anemic Success Story In Audio History

By Author: Jeff Noctis
Total Articles: 47
Comment this article

Though the MiniDisc may have faded away from popularity, there is still marginal use in some parts of the world. Known today as Hi-MD, the format has come a long way in respects of its usability. Originally released in late 1992, MiniDiscs were intended to replace the analog audio cassette. First, however, Sony had to battle two other new formats that were also contenders in the attempt to replace the analog cassette tape.

The MiniDisc Wins the Format War But So What

The Digital Audio Tape (DAT) was doing well in professional recording studios but never caught on with the general public. Only a small number of prerecorded music DATs were produced and sold to the public.

Philips took the logical step of offering backwards compatibility by introducing a digital tape format called the Digital Compact Cassette. The DCC met with direct competition from Sony's MiniDisc and both prerecorded DCCs and MiniDiscs of popular artists were released and marketed to consumers. The magneto-optical disc technology allowed for random access of music, and withstood shock better. Although DCC was backwards compatible with the ...
... standard audio cassette, the market clearly favored MiniDiscs, and DCC was discontinued in 1996.

MiniDiscs however were never able to achieve a high level of success and were no real threat to the compact disc or even the analog cassette. Both MiniDiscs and standard cassettes were no match for the CD once CD-R technology became available. People were then able to record their music collections to CD. In the end, the compact disc moved on to become the undisputed king of the music sector. The MiniDisc floundered, then attempted a comeback of sorts, floundered some more and has now fallen by the wayside.

Limitations of the MiniDisc

Consumers were slow to adopt the MiniDisc for several reasons. Although more popular in Japan and Europe, only a limited amount of prerecorded music became available in the US - mostly new releases from Sony Music Entertainment labels. Also, recording on the MD format was notably frustrating for many people. Initially, there was no way to transfer the audio tracks from a PC to the MiniDisc and vice versa.

Sony responded to this problem by introducing software specifically designed for the purpose. This software also had issues in early releases regarding security and copyright locks that prevented the song from being further copied after being copied from the player. The newer Hi-MD has sought to address these issues, although sound files are still encrypted and decrypted when transferred, unlike standard files that are transferred directly. This means that the software must be active for all playable music transfers, which has been inconvenient to some consumers.

Even after the MiniDisc format received a makeover in the form of Hi-MD technology in 2004, not all of the issues that plagued the MiniDisc could be resolved. The Hi-MDs themselves can only hold one Gigabyte of music, and solid-state MP3 players simply had them beat for storage capacity and play times.

Conclusion

The MiniDisc is something of an oddity in audio history. Its innovation came at a time that made it almost obsolete before it was ever able to get off the ground. It failed in the music market because the older generations preferred audio cassettes and CDs, and the younger generation loved compact discs and eventually mp3 players. MDs suffered limitations with storage capacity that solid-state music players rapidly out paced. The inability to copy music to one's computer and vice versa also led to difficulties for the MiniDisc in popular use. At this point in time, MiniDiscs are pretty much gone. If you have any personal or family speech or music recordings, now is the time to get them transferred to a different format.

Audible Forensics offers both audio transfer and forensic audio services. We can transfer multiple audio formats including MiniDiscs, DAT, DCC, and microcassette to CD or a digital file format such as wav or mp3.