ALL >> Business >> View Article
Why Not Just Teach The Contest Of Interpretations Between Formalist And Political
What of all those who do How are we to evaluate their quality Or are they to be banned from English studies Fish was a Yale grad student in the days of Cleanth Brooks & Company, and I've always thought his multiple theoretical phases were basically variations on the New Criticism, with all its blind spots—for example, toward literary realism, romantic-transcendentalist poetic theory ("Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world"),and existentialist litterature engages. Thomas Sabo Bracelets Why not just teach "the contest of interpretations" between formalist and political or moral approaches without pre-judgment.
In another formulation, Fish says, "The only advocacy that goes on in the classroom is the advocacy of what James Murphy has identified as the intellectual virtues, 'thoroughness, perseverance, intellectual honesty,' components of the cardinal academic virtue of being 'conscientious in the pursuit of truth.' If you're not in the pursuit-of-truth business, you should not be in the university". Leaving aside Fish's voluminous ...
... writings on the problematic nature of truth and its pursuit, let's again pursue the consequences of his arguments here. Suppose we take as a subject of academic study the obstacles posed to the pursuit of truth in a society in which public opinion is manipulated by political and corporate forces spending billions of dollars annually to produce propaganda, deception, outright lies, and other more-or-less toxic forms of "spin." (When Fish and other theoretical deep thinkers like Barbara Herrnstein Smith address the subject of truth, it is almost invariably on an abstract epistemological level, avoiding the epistemology of deliberate lying or propaganda.) Shouldn't those of us in the pursuit-of-truth business devote a major part of our teaching and scholarship to dissecting and assessing all these sources of fallacious argument, as a purely academic enterprise! Shouldn't we also perhaps take an advocacy position—opposing the systematic stupefaction of the entire American polity and culture, with the same fervor Fish recommends for opposing cuts in spending for liberal education In other words, might not the advocacy of "intellectual honesty" take on the force of the kind of moral imperative that Fish claims to eschew, in the manner of Emerson's exhortation to the American Scholar: "See it to be a lie, and you have already dealt it its mortal blow", or Chomsky's "Intellectuals are in a position to expose the lies of government, to analyze actions according to their causes and motives and often hidden intentions"
Also suppose, just hypothetically, that "the superiority of one analysis or description or prescription over its (intellectual) rivals"—say, the intellectual superiority of one political party or ideology in America over others— Thomas Sabo Jewellery can be established by "argument and evidence" Suppose further that one party not only constantly flaunts its anti-intellectualism but is expressly committed to the following view, attributed by journalist Ron Suskind to an "unnamed [Bush] administration official".
Add Comment
Business Articles
1. Finding A Trusted Sustainability Consultant In Abu DhabiAuthor: Agile Advisors
2. Iso Certification In Dubai – Advantages For Business
Author: Agile Advisors
3. Best Forex Brokers List | Best Broker For Forex Trading 2024
Author: Top Forex Brokers Review
4. Celebrate Achievements With Customized, High-quality Awards From Trophy Deals
Author: Trophy Deals
5. Is 100% Company Ownership Possible For Expats In Saudi Arabia?
Author: jodonjo
6. We Are Hiring: Senior Executive - Indirect Taxation In Gurgaon!
Author: tanvir Khan
7. Ceratec Tower 1o8: The Eventual Fate Of Business Greatness In Balewadi, Pune
Author: Tarun
8. Enrofloxacin Manufacturer: Swisschemie
Author: Swisschemie
9. Ultimate Guide To Hotels In Mussoorie: Discover The Best Places To Stay, Including Hr Hotels And Resorts
Author: Hr Hotels and Resort
10. How Quickly Do Fast Cash Loans Online Pay Out Cash On The Same Day?
Author: Lucy Lloyd
11. Leading Digital Marketing Agency In Hyderabad And Unlock Your Brand’s Potential With Sanbrains Agency
Author: Sanbrains Seo
12. Celebrate Success With Customized Awards From Trophy Deals
Author: Trophy Deals
13. Title: Choosing The Right Humidity Stability Chamber Supplier For Your Manufacturing Needs
Author: bio gene
14. Complete Guide To Studying Mbbs In Poland
Author: Mbbs Blog
15. What Is The Process For Locating The Best Lender For Short Term Loans Online?
Author: Robert Miller