How To Choose The Best Property Management Company In New Orleans: What To Look For?

By Author: Coxe Property Management
Total Articles: 22
Comment this article

Finding the right property manager can make or break your real estate investment experience—especially in a vibrant and complex rental market like New Orleans. Whether you're managing a single rental property in New Orleans, a growing portfolio across Metairie, or furnished apartments in neighborhoods like Gert Town, choosing a trusted partner is crucial.
But how do you know who to trust with your property, tenants, and income?
In this article, we break down exactly what to look for when selecting the best property management in New Orleans, from services to local knowledge, legal expertise, and customer service.

Why Choosing the Right Property Manager Matters?

A good property manager doesn’t just collect rent—they protect your investment, ensure tenant satisfaction, reduce vacancy rates, and help you stay legally compliant. The wrong manager, however, can lead to long-term vacancies, legal troubles, poor tenant relationships, and loss of income.

1. Look for Local Market Expertise
The first thing you want is a company that knows the New Orleans rental market inside and out.
Are ...
... they familiar with pricing trends in Metairie vs. Gert Town?
Can they guide you on seasonal vacancy fluctuations in Lakeview?
Do they understand what tenants are looking for in furnished apartments in New Orleans?

An experienced local team can help you attract the right tenants, price your property accurately, and navigate any city-specific regulations.

2. Services You Actually Need
Not all New Orleans property management companies offer the same services. Some may focus only on tenant placement, while others provide full-service management from A to Z.
Make sure the company you choose offers:
Rent collection and accounting
Maintenance and repairs
Tenant screening and leasing
Property inspections
Eviction handling
Legal guidance

If you have multiple properties or units, look for someone who can scale services accordingly.

3. Transparency in Fees
Understand their fee structure upfront. Reputable property managers in New Orleans will offer clear pricing for:
Monthly management fees
Tenant placement fees
Maintenance markups (if any)
Eviction or legal service charges
Avoid companies with hidden fees or vague contracts. Clarity from day one builds trust.

4. Strong Communication & Responsiveness
Your property manager will be your eyes and ears on the ground. They need to communicate clearly and regularly.
Ask:
How often will I receive updates?
Do I get a monthly report?
Will I have access to a portal for real-time updates?
Who handles tenant communication?

Whether your property is in Metairie or downtown New Orleans, you deserve consistent updates and quick responses.

5. Legal Knowledge is a Must
New Orleans property management is governed by city, state, and federal regulations. A good manager helps you:
Stay compliant with fair housing laws
Handle evictions legally
Draft and enforce lease agreements
Navigate short-term rental ordinances (especially for furnished apartments)

This expertise helps avoid fines, lawsuits, and tenant disputes.

6. Reputation and References
Online reviews, client testimonials, and years in business matter. Look for a company that has:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Google reviews
Testimonials from landlords with similar properties
Membership in industry associations (like NARPM or BBB)
A professional, transparent website

Ask for references or case studies specific to your type of property—whether it’s a rental home in Gert Town or a condo in Metairie.

7. Technology and Owner Portals
Modern New Orleans property managers should offer:
Online rent collection
Maintenance request tracking
Owner dashboards
Mobile-friendly communication
These features save time and improve tenant satisfaction—important for long-term retention.

8. Tenant Screening That Works
Tenant quality = property quality. Choose a company with a thorough screening process that includes:
Credit & background checks
Income verification
Rental history checks
Employment confirmation
This reduces evictions, damages, and turnover.

9. Maintenance Network
Ask how they handle maintenance:
Do they have in-house staff or trusted vendors?
Are repairs handled quickly and professionally?
Are costs passed through fairly?
A slow maintenance response can lead to unhappy tenants and property deterioration.

10. Customized Solutions Based on Property Type
Managing a single-family home in Jefferson is different from overseeing furnished apartments in New Orleans. Your ideal manager should customize services based on:
Property type (apartment vs. house vs. luxury unit)
Location (urban, student area, suburbs)
Target tenant (families, professionals, students, etc.)

Quick Checklist: Questions to Ask Property Managers
How many properties do you currently manage in New Orleans?
Do you provide 24/7 emergency maintenance?
What is your tenant screening process?
What’s your average vacancy turnaround time?
How do you handle legal issues or evictions?
Do you manage properties in Metairie, Gert Town, or Jefferson
How often will I receive financial reports?
The Coxe Property Management Difference
If you're looking for reliable, locally experienced, and results-driven property management in New Orleans, Coxe Property Management and Leasing checks every box.
Over 30 years in the New Orleans market
24/7 availability
Trusted with nearly $1 billion in assets
Personalized boutique service
Full-service leasing, maintenance, legal, and financial reporting
Areas served include: New Orleans, Metairie, Kenner, Gert Town, Lakeview, and more

Whether you have a vacant unit, need help with tenant issues, or want to grow your rental portfolio—Coxe is your trusted local partner.

Final Thoughts

Choosing a property manager is not just about delegating work—it's about protecting and growing your investment. In a competitive market like New Orleans, the right company can save you thousands of dollars in missed rent, vacancies, and legal issues.
Make sure you ask the right questions, look for local expertise, and choose a team that treats your property like their own.

Ready to simplify your rental journey?
Call Coxe Property Management and Leasing at 1-228-229-6373 Or visit coxepropertymanagementandleasing dot com