Md5 Collisions And The Impact On Computer Forensics

By Author: Wisemonkeys
Total Articles: 277
Comment this article

Abstract:The Message Digest 5 (MD5) hash is commonly used as for integrity verification in the forensic imaging process. The ability to force MD5 hash collisions has been a reality for more than a decade, although there is a general consensus that hash collisions are of minimal impact to the practice of computer forensics. This paper describes an experiment to determine the results of imaging two disks that are identical except for one file, the two versions of which have different content but otherwise occupy the same byte positions on the disk, are the same size, and have the same hash value.

Keyword: MD5,Computer forensics,Collisions

I.INTRODUCTION:
A popular cryptographic hash function called MD5 was originally thought to be a trustworthy way to check the accuracy of data. The MD5 technique, however, has recently been found to contain collisions, which means that it is possible to generate two distinct inputs that result in the same hash value. This has important ramifications for the science of computer forensics since it suddenly becomes easy to fabricate data that would look real when checked against ...
... an MD5 hash. This can cast doubt on the reliability of forensic evidence and obstruct criminal investigations. Because of this, many businesses and people have stopped using MD5 in favour of more robust hashing algorithms like SHA-256 or SHA-3 to protect the integrity of their data.

A. Definition of Hashing?
Hashing consists of converting a general string of information into an intricate piece of data. This is done to scramble the data so that it completely transforms the original value, making the hashed value utterly different from the original.

Hashing uses a hash function to convert standard data into an unrecognizable format. These hash functions are a set of mathematical calculations that transform the original information into their hashed values, known as the hash digest or digest in general. The digest size is always the same for a particular hash function like MD5 or SHA1, irrespective of input size.

What is hashing?

B. Definition of MD5?

The hash algorithm MD5(Message Digest Method 5) generates a 128-bit hash value from 512-bit blocks of data. The message is padded to make its bits-per-character length correspond to 448 modulo 512. Even if the message is the appropriate length, it is always padded. The padded message is added 64 bits to make it an integer multiple of 512 bits, representing the size of the original message in bits.

Figure 2: MD5 (Message Digest Method 5)

C. Overview of the MD5 hash function

The MD5 hash function was designed as a secure tool for generating a unique representation of the original data, in the form of a 128-bit hash value. The algorithm operates by breaking down the input message into 512-bit blocks, and then performing a series of mathematical operations on them to generate the 128-bit hash. These operations include a combination of bitwise, logical, and arithmetic operations, which are executed in a specific order as defined by the MD5 specification.

One of the primary goals of the MD5 hash function was to create a one-way function, meaning that the original message should not be able to be reconstructed from the hash value. This property makes it ideal for use in cryptographic applications where data integrity needs to be verified. For example, when two parties need to exchange data securely, they can use the MD5 hash function to verify that the received data has not been tampered with during the transmission process.

However, over time, weaknesses in the MD5 algorithm were discovered. For example, it was shown that the MD5 hash function was vulnerable to collision attacks. This means that it is possible for an attacker to find two different messages that produce the same 128-bit hash value, which could allow them to alter the contents of a file or message, while still maintaining the same hash value. This would make it appear as though the original data had not been changed, even though it had.

Due to these weaknesses, the use of the MD5 hash function is no longer recommended for secure cryptographic applications. Instead, stronger hash functions such as SHA-256 or SHA-3 are recommended for secure applications.

II. How MD5 works

The MD5 message-digest hashing method analyses data in 512-bit strings, which are then divided into 16 words of 32 bits each. MD5 generates a 128-bit message digest value.

The MD5 digest value is produced in steps that analyse each 512-bit block of data along with the value computed in the previous stage. The message-digest values are initialised using successive hexadecimal numerical numbers in the first step. Each stage has four message-digest passes that modify values in the current data block as well as values processed from the preceding block. The last number calculated from the previous block is the MD5 digest for that block.

Example of how the MD5 algorithm works:

1. Input message: "Hello World"

2. Padding: The message is padded to make its length in bits congruent to 448 modulo 512. The length of the original message in bits is represented by 64 bits and is appended to the padded message.

3. Initialization: The MD5 algorithm starts by initializing four 32-bit variables, called "registers", with specific values.

4. Processing: The padded message is processed in 512-bit blocks, and the operations performed on each block result in changes to the values stored in the four registers. The operations performed include logical and arithmetic operations, such as bitwise rotations, bitwise logical operations, and modular arithmetic operations.

5. Finalization: After processing all the blocks, the final values stored in the registers are concatenated to form a 128-bit hash value, which represents the digital fingerprint of the original message.

A. Characteristics of MD5 hash values:

The MD5 hash function is known for the following characteristics:

Fixed Length Output: The MD5 hash function always produces a 128-bit (16-byte) hash value, regardless of the size or length of the input message.

Unique Output: For a given input message, the MD5 hash function always generates a unique hash value. This means that even the slightest change in the input message will result in a completely different hash value.

Ir-reversibility: The MD5 hash function is designed to be a one-way function, meaning it is not possible to recreate the original message from the hash value.

Collision Resistant: The MD5 hash function is considered collision-resistant, meaning it is computationally infeasible to find two different input messages that produce the same hash value.

Deterministic: The MD5 hash function is deterministic, meaning that the same input message will always produce the same hash value, making it ideal for use in integrity checks and digital signatures.

Fast Computation: The MD5 hash function is relatively fast and efficient, making it ideal for use in applications that need to generate a hash value for large input messages.

This is an important characteristic of the MD5 hash function, as it allows for consistent and standardized comparison of hash values. It is also useful in scenarios where a fixed-length output is required, such as digital signatures and other cryptographic applications.

D. Common uses of MD5

MD5 is widely used in various applications due to its simplicity, fast computation, and ability to produce a fixed-length hash value.
Some common uses of MD5 include:

Digital Signatures: MD5 is used to generate a hash value of digital signatures for authenticating digital certificates, email signatures, and software packages.

Password Verification: MD5 is used to store and verify passwords in many websites and applications, as it is computationally infeasible to reverse the hash value to obtain the original password.

File Integrity Verification: MD5 is often used to verify the integrity of large files and data sets. The hash value of a file can be computed and then compared to the original hash value to detect any modifications made to the file.

Data Caching: MD5 is used in data caching applications to index and quickly retrieve cached content.

Network Communications: MD5 is used in network protocols, such as SCTP, to ensure the integrity of data transmitted between two systems.

III. MD5 Collisions

A. Methods for finding collisions in MD5:

There are several methods for finding collisions in MD5, including the following:

Brute force attack: A brute force attack involves trying every possible input message until a collision is found. However, this method is infeasible for MD5 due to the large number of possible messages and the large number of hash computations required.

Birthday attack: The birthday attack is a statistical approach that takes advantage of the birthday paradox to find collisions. The birthday paradox states that in a group of 23 people, there is a 50% chance that two people have the same birthday. The birthday attack works by generating a large number of random messages and checking for collisions.

Collision-finding algorithms: Researchers have developed specialized algorithms that are specifically designed to find collisions in MD5. These algorithms use mathematical techniques, such as linear and differential cryptanalysis, to analyze the MD5 hash function and find collisions.

Distributed attacks: Distributed attacks are a type of attack in which the attacker uses multiple computers to perform the collision search. This increases the computational power available for the attack and allows the attacker to find collisions more quickly.

C. Real-world examples of MD5 collisions:

1. File Tampering: One of the most well-known examples of an MD5 collision is the ability to tamper with a file while maintaining its hash value. This makes it appear that the file has not been changed, while in reality, it has.

2. Certificate Forgery: In 2010, a security researcher demonstrated the ability to create a rogue SSL certificate with the same MD5 hash as a legitimate certificate. This would allow an attacker to intercept encrypted communications and present a fake certificate to the user, appearing as a trusted source.

3. Digital Signatures: MD5 collisions can also be used to forge digital signatures, allowing an attacker to create a malicious file that appears to be signed by a trusted source.

4. Password Hashes: MD5 is often used to hash passwords, but its vulnerability to collision attacks makes it an insecure choice for this purpose. An attacker could create two different passwords with the same hash value, making it easier to crack the password hashes.

IV. Impact of MD5 Collisions on Computer Forensics

MD5 collisions can have a major impact on computer forensics as they can be used to create malicious files that can be used to bypass security protocols. This makes it difficult for computer forensics to accurately analyze digital evidence, as malicious files can be created that look like legitimate files.

Computer forensics is the science of acquiring, analyzing, and preserving electronic data in a manner that is suitable for presentation in a court of law. It involves the identification, collection, examination, and analysis of digital evidence in order to answer questions related to a crime or violation of policy.

The process of computer forensics typically involves the following steps:

Seizure: The first step in computer forensics is the seizure of electronic evidence. This could be done as part of a criminal investigation, or in response to a civil dispute or regulatory request.

Preservation: The next step is to preserve the electronic evidence so that it can be analyzed without altering its original state. This is typically done by making a bit-by-bit copy of the electronic data, which can then be analyzed without affecting the original evidence.

Analysis: The electronic evidence is then analyzed to identify and extract relevant data. This involves the use of specialized software tools and techniques to recover deleted or hidden files, as well as to identify patterns and relationships in the data.

Reporting: The final step is to present the findings of the analysis in a manner that is suitable for presentation in a court of law. This typically involves the preparation of a detailed report that documents the methods and results of the analysis, as well as any relevant conclusions.

B. Importance of accuracy in computer forensics

Accuracy is a critical aspect of computer forensics because the results of the forensic analysis can have significant consequences in criminal, civil, or regulatory proceedings. Inaccurate results can lead to false accusations or erroneous evidence, while accurate results can support the case and establish the credibility of the evidence.

To ensure accuracy, computer forensics professionals follow a strict set of procedures and protocols. These procedures include the proper handling of evidence to avoid contamination or alteration, the use of secure and validated tools to perform the analysis, and the documentation of every step of the process to ensure transparency and accountability.

In addition, computer forensics professionals must also consider the possibility of data manipulation or alteration, either deliberately or accidentally. For example, an attacker may have deleted or encrypted evidence to conceal their actions, or a user may have unknowingly modified data during normal use. To address these challenges, computer forensics professionals use specialized tools and techniques to recover data from damaged or deleted files, and to identify any tampering or alteration of the data.

Overall, accuracy is crucial in computer forensics because the results of the analysis can have far-reaching consequences, both for the individuals and organizations involved, and for the legal system as a whole.

C. MD5's role in computer forensics

MD5 hash values are commonly used in computer forensics to verify the authenticity and integrity of digital evidence. In many forensic investigations, it is important to be able to determine if a file or disk image has been altered in any way, as this could potentially compromise the evidentiary value of the data. By computing the MD5 hash value for a file or disk image and then comparing it to the expected hash value, forensic examiners can quickly and easily determine if the data has been tampered with. This can be especially useful when dealing with large amounts of data, as computing the MD5 hash value is a fast and efficient process.

Additionally, the fixed-length output of the MD5 hash function can be used as a unique identifier for a file or disk image. This can be helpful in situations where it is necessary to keep track of multiple copies of the same data, or where it is important to establish a clear chain of custody for the evidence.

D. How collisions in MD5 can compromise computer forensics

Collisions in MD5 can compromise computer forensics in several ways:

Tampering with Evidence: A malicious attacker can modify a file and generate a new message with the same MD5 hash as the original, which could compromise the authenticity of the digital evidence. The altered file could be presented as the original, making it difficult for computer forensic analysts to detect any tampering.

Confusion in Digital Fingerprinting: Digital fingerprinting is a common technique in computer forensics that uses hash values to identify and track digital files. If collisions exist in the MD5 hash function, then it's possible for two different files to have the same hash value, which could result in confusion and misinterpretation of the digital evidence.

Inaccurate Evidence Analysis: Computer forensic analysts rely on the accuracy of the hash values to validate the authenticity of digital evidence. If the MD5 hash function is susceptible to collisions, then the integrity of the evidence could be compromised, which could lead to inaccurate results and incorrect conclusions.

Therefore, it is important to use stronger hash functions, such as SHA-256 or SHA-3, in computer forensics to ensure the accuracy and integrity of digital evidence.

E. Alternatives to MD5 for Computer Forensics

There are several alternatives to the MD5 hash function that can be used in computer forensics. Some of the most popular alternatives include:

SHA-1 (Secure Hash Algorithm 1): This is a more secure version of the MD5 hash function and generates a 160-bit hash value. It is widely used in digital certificates and other security applications.

SHA-256: This is a more secure version of the SHA-1 hash function and generates a 256-bit hash value. It is widely used in cryptocurrency and other security applications.

SHA-3: This is a new family of hash functions that were selected through a public competition. They offer improved security over previous hash functions and are widely used in security applications.

BLAKE2: This is a new hash function that is faster and more secure than previous hash functions. It is widely used in security applications and is the recommended alternative to MD5 by the IETF.

In computer forensics, the use of these hash functions is important for verifying the integrity of electronic evidence. If the evidence has been tampered with, the hash value will change, and this will alert the forensic analyst to the fact that the evidence may have been compromised. Therefore, it is important to use a secure and reliable hash function in computer forensics.

V. Conclusion

1. MD5 is a widely used hash function in computer forensics but has been shown to be vulnerable to collision attacks.

2. Collisions in MD5 can compromise the accuracy and reliability of forensic investigations.

3. With the ability to create two different messages with the same MD5 hash value, forensic examiners must take precautions to ensure the integrity of their evidence.

4. In some cases, collisions in MD5 can lead to incorrect conclusions in forensic investigations and wrongly implicate individuals or organizations.

5. The use of alternative hash functions, such as SHA-256 or SHA-3, can provide a higher level of security in computer forensics and reduce the risk of collisions.

6. The importance of verifying the integrity of digital evidence cannot be overstated and is crucial for the proper functioning of the legal system.

7. The use of multiple hash functions and signature verification methods can also increase the accuracy and reliability of forensic investigations.

8. The continued advancement of technology and cryptography may require computer forensic experts to regularly update their methods and tools to maintain the highest level of accuracy.

References

Den Boer B, Bosselaers A. Collisions for the compression function of MD5, Advances in Cryptology e EUROCRYPT’93. LNCS 765; 1994. p. 293e304.

Dobbertin Hans. Cryptanalysis of MD5 compress. German Information Security Agency; May 1996.

MD5 collisions and the impact on computer forensics 39

Patterson Wayne. Mathematical cryptology for computer scientists and mathematicians. Rowman & Littlefield, Pub#lishers; 1987. p. 156e8.

Schneier Bruce. Applied cryptography, second edition proto#cols, algorithms and source code in C. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 1996. p. 436e41.

Schneier Bruce. Opinion: cryptanalysis of MD5 and SHA: time for a new standard. Computerworld; April 19,2004.

Wang Xianyan, Feng Dengguo, Lai Xuejia, Yu Hongbo. Collisions for hash functions MD4, MD5 Haval-128 and RIPEMD. CRYPTO’04; Revised August 17, 2004.

"Collisions in the Full SHA-1" by Xiaoyun Wang, Yiqun Lisa Yin, Hongbo Yu (2005)

"How to Break MD5 and Other Hash Functions" by Xiaoyun Wang, Yiqun Lisa Yin, and Hongbo Yu (2007)

"Improved collision attacks on SHA-1" by Marc Stevens (2007)

"Cryptographic hash function" by Christophe De Cannière and Bart Preneel (2009)

"A New Multicollision Algorithm for MD5" by B. Liu, J. Wang, and J. Zhang (2010)

"Collision Attacks on MD5" by Marc Stevens (2010)

"Computer Forensics and the Role of Hash Functions in the Digital Investigation Process" by R.D.B. Walker and J.P. Anderson (2010)

"The Impact of Cryptographic Hashing Algorithms on Digital Forensics" by R.D.B. Walker and J.P. Anderson (2011)

"An Analysis of the MD5 Algorithm and Its Use in Digital Forensics" by J.A. Segura, L.G. Zaitseva, and M. Peinado (2013)

"The Future of Hash Functions in Digital Forensics" by J.A. Segura and L.G. Zaitseva (2014).

It is said that "Knowledge is Power" and Wisemonkeys(https://wisemonkeys.info/) is the ideal platform to prove this right where this blog was posted. Additionally, when knowledge is free it should be shared. Therefore, keeping this in mind Wisemonkeys an LMS platform is developed so that people can exchange their ideas, knowledge, and experiences for the wise Gen Z.

SIGN UP(https://me.wisemonkeys.info/login) TODAY and upgrade your knowledge base.