ALL >> Insurance >> View Article
Break The Monopoly — Buy Policies Across State Lines

Let's leave the politics of healthcare reform to one side and focus on a proposal to change the law to allow free market competition between insurers in different states. A policy consistently mentioned by the Republican party is to break the state monopolies in the insurance market. Since the 1800's, the individual states have claimed the sole right to regulate the sale of insurance within their own borders. Each state has asserted the right to license insurance companies and to set the terms on which they can conduct business. This has led to a patchwork of different sets of regulations with each state creating unique laws. In turn, this forces an insurance company to set up separate subsidiaries to trade in each state. No licensed company can sell a policy to someone who has a residence in another state. There was a brief moment in 1944 when a decision of the Supreme Court allowed the possibility of federal supervision. But the lawmakers in Washington immediately changed the law to retain state control. Why is this a bad thing? The national insurance companies have divided up the states between them and choose not to compete ...
... against each other. This keeps the number of insurance companies in each state artificially low and, because there is no real competition, premium rates are higher than they should be for weak policy terms.
You are reading this article on the internet. When online, you can buy more or less any product or service across state or national boundaries. Although there are some restrictions, e.g. some states limit your right to import drugs from foreign countries, there is an almost free market where you can search for the cheapest price and buy whatever you need. There is no possible economic justification for retaining this historical privilege for insurance companies. All it does is preserve their ability to maximize their profits at your expense. For example, in Minnesota three insurance companies dominate 80% of the market for health plans. There is no doubt that, if more companies entered the market, the premium rates would fall. During his run for President, Senator John McCain was in favor of free markets for health plans. President Obama supports it and the proposal is in both versions of the healthcare reform bills currently stalled in Washington. But because the Republican party's only policy is to oppose everything the Democrats propose, it seems even this simple change in the law may be lost. What will the result be? The anticompetitive behavior of the insurance industry will continue and you, the consumer, will suffer.
Could the law change tomorrow and allow everyone access to cheap health insurance wherever it can be found? The problem is that the states have different sets of regulations and compliance leads to different costs. The playing fields are not level. So, premiums are significantly lower in those states which have the fewest consumer protections. It would not be fair competition if people living in Minnesota, which has strong consumer protections, could all get health insurance quotes from states with little or no consumer protections. The only way in which there could be a free market is to have a single set of federal regulations for the sale of health insurance plans. Sadly, the political parties do not want to talk about this even though we would all benefit. In the US, the political elite's interests do not match the needs of the ordinary citizens.
Add Comment
Insurance Articles
1. Innovations In Music: The Latest Trends In Instruments And Musicians CoverageAuthor: micheljordan4
2. Abha Health Id: Your Easy Key To Better Healthcare Access
Author: Nilanjan Das
3. Why Music Teachers Need Insurance Now More Than Ever?
Author: musicinstrumentsins
4. How Do I Insure An Expensive Piano?
Author: victor12johnson
5. Why Every Guitarist Should Protect Their Most Treasured Instrument?
Author: Clarionins
6. Why The Bassoon Is The Breakout Star Of 2025’s Indie Fusion Movement?
Author: musicinstrumentsins
7. Essential Business Insurance Every Recording Studio Needs
Author: victor12johnson
8. Beyond The Music: Secure Your Viola With Coverage You Can Trust
Author: micheljordan4
9. Balancing Growth And Security: How Strategic Finance Drives Smarter Investing
Author: Drishti Desai
10. What Happens If Your Clarinet Is Lost Or Damaged By An Airline?
Author: musicinstrumentsins
11. Classic Car Auto Insurance In California: Protect Your Vintage Ride
Author: Namaste Insurance Agency
12. How To Choose The Best Insurance Plan For Your Musical Instrument Repair Business?
Author: victor12johnson
13. How Cloud-based Invoicing Services Streamline Financial Management
Author: SourceThrive
14. What Happens When You Don’t Insure Your Audio Gear?
Author: micheljordan4
15. The Hidden Risks Of Not Insuring Your Musical Instrument
Author: musicinstrumentsins